Aaron Rodgers ranks third in Chris Simms’ all-time NFL QBs list

Aaron Rodgers has been named the third-best quarterback in NFL history by analyst Chris Simms, placing him behind only Tom Brady and Peyton Manning in the latest top-10 ranking.

What did Chris Simms say?

Chris Simms, the former NFL quarterback turned analyst, unveiled his personal ranking of the league’s 10 greatest signal-callers on 18 July 2026. Rodgers sits third on the list, sandwiched between Brady at No. 1 and Manning at No. 2. The order reflects Simms’ view of peak performance, longevity, and impact on the game.

Why it matters for Aaron Rodgers

Rodgers’ placement confirms his standing among the NFL’s elite, even as he approaches the back half of his career. Simms’ list is notable for its blunt hierarchy: Brady tops the chart, Manning slots just below, and Rodgers follows as the clear-cut third option. That trio alone underscores the generational gap Rodgers has navigated since taking over for Brett Favre in Green Bay.

How the ranking breaks down

Simms’ top 10 includes a mix of eras and styles. Rodgers is the highest-ranked active player, with Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen rounding out the next tier. The list also features legends like Joe Montana, Dan Marino, and Steve Young, each separated by narrow margins in Simms’ eyes. Rodgers’ inclusion hinges on four MVP awards, a Super Bowl XLV win, and a reputation for precision under pressure.

What comes next for Rodgers

The ranking arrives as Rodgers eyes a potential 20th NFL season. Speculation swirls around his future with the Green Bay Packers, though no official word has emerged. For now, the nod from Simms serves as fresh validation of Rodgers’ legacy-one that keeps him locked in the same conversation as the game’s immortals.