Caleb Williams' trade value lags behind Drake Maye by two first-round picks

Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams is worth four first-round picks in a hypothetical trade, according to ESPN's Bill Barnwell. That’s two fewer than New England Patriots QB Drake Maye, who is valued at six first-rounders.

How does Caleb Williams' trade value compare to other QBs?

Williams' projected value matches Cincinnati Bengals star Joe Burrow. However, he falls short of Maye, who nearly won MVP and reached the Super Bowl. Jayden Daniels, the Washington Commanders QB, is valued lower at three first-round picks plus extra capital.

Why is Williams worth less than Maye?

Despite leading a last-second comeback in the 2025 playoffs, Williams threw three interceptions and had the worst completion percentage over expectation in the regular season. His ceiling remains high, but inconsistency keeps him below Maye’s tier.

What’s next for Williams in 2026?

The Bears hope Williams improves his accuracy and surpasses 4,000 passing yards this season. If he does, his trade value could rise to match or even exceed Maye’s. For now, Chicago views him as priceless-a QB who ended their mediocrity and gave fans hope.

Williams was drafted No. 1 overall in 2024, while Maye went third. Both are still young, and their values could shift dramatically after the 2026 season.