Clayton Oliver snubbed in AFL Player of the Year votes for Round 18

Clayton Oliver was left out of SEN’s AFL Player of the Year votes for Round 18, despite strong performances in Melbourne’s 111-65 win over Richmond on July 14, 2026. The midfielder’s exclusion has raised eyebrows among fans and analysts alike, as he continues to be a key figure for the Demons.

What happened in Round 18?

The SEN panel awarded votes across eight matches, with Clayton Oliver notably missing from the GWS Giants vs. Geelong game. The Giants won 86-73, but Oliver’s absence from the top three vote-getters-Shaun Mannagh (3), Sam Taylor (2), and Toby Greene (1)-has drawn criticism. The panel acknowledged Oliver’s impact, calling him 'sooooooo stiff' in their notes.

Why was Clayton Oliver snubbed?

While the SEN votes are subjective, Oliver’s exclusion comes despite his consistent form this season. The 27-year-old has been a driving force for Melbourne, and his absence from the votes in a tight game has led to speculation about whether the panel undervalued his contributions. Fans and pundits have taken to social media to express their frustration, arguing that Oliver’s influence should have earned him recognition.

How does this affect the Player of the Year race?

With the season entering its final stages, the Player of the Year race is heating up. Nick Daicos (Collingwood) leads with 29 votes, followed by Marcus Bontempelli (Western Bulldogs) with 25. Clayton Oliver, however, is not among the top vote-getters, despite his importance to Melbourne’s campaign. The snub in Round 18 could impact his chances of finishing in the top 10, though his team’s success may still keep him in contention.

What’s next for Clayton Oliver?

Melbourne will look to Oliver to maintain his strong form as they push for a finals berth. The midfielder’s ability to control the midfield will be crucial in the remaining rounds, and fans will be watching closely to see if he can bounce back from this snub with standout performances. The next round of votes will be closely scrutinized to see if Oliver receives the recognition many believe he deserves.