Josh Allen and Patrick Mahomes share record trade value in NFL

Josh Allen and Patrick Mahomes have been deemed equally valuable in a new NFL trade analysis, with each quarterback assigned a staggering worth of seven first-round picks. The Buffalo Bills and Kansas City Chiefs stars are considered the most untouchable assets in the league, according to ESPN's Bill Barnwell.

What does the trade value mean?

The valuation places both quarterbacks in an unprecedented category. No player has ever been traded for seven first-round picks, and the sheer volume of assets required would likely necessitate additional deals to amass enough capital. Barnwell notes that while Allen has outperformed Mahomes in recent regular seasons, Mahomes' postseason success and consistency before 2025 give him equal standing.

Why is this significant for Josh Allen?

Allen's trade value underscores his status as one of the NFL's elite quarterbacks. Barnwell argues that Allen is currently the best quarterback in football, citing his performance over the past three seasons. However, Mahomes' postseason achievements and longevity add to his appeal, making the two quarterbacks virtually interchangeable in terms of value.

How does Mahomes' injury affect the valuation?

Mahomes' recovery from a torn ACL is a factor, but Barnwell suggests it's largely theoretical. The Chiefs are unlikely to trade their franchise quarterback, and the same goes for the Bills with Allen. Despite the potential hesitation due to Mahomes' age and injury, his decade of high-level play solidifies his worth.

What's the history between Allen and Mahomes?

Allen has mostly gotten the better of Mahomes in the regular season, while Mahomes has had the edge in the playoffs. This dynamic adds another layer to their equal valuation, as their head-to-head performances highlight different strengths. Regardless of their individual achievements, both quarterbacks are at the pinnacle of the NFL.