Josh Allen's Postseason Performance Sparks Debate Among NFL Experts

Josh Allen's postseason performance has been a topic of discussion among NFL experts, with some questioning his status as one of the league's top quarterbacks.

What happened?

The Buffalo Bills' quarterback had a disappointing game against the Denver Broncos in 2025, throwing two interceptions and fumbling twice. Despite throwing for 283 yards and running for 66, his overall play was largely disappointing.

Why it matters for Josh Allen

The performance against the Broncos was a significant blow to the Bills' chances of winning the Super Bowl, and it has raised questions about Allen's ability to perform under pressure. As one of the most prolific quarterbacks in recent memory, the onus of expectations has been through the roof.

What comes next?

Former NFL MVP Cam Newton has weighed in on the matter, sharing his thoughts on Allen's performance. Newton, who has been impressed by Allen's abilities, believes that the quarterback doesn't get the blame like other superstars in the league.

"But this is the thing about Josh Allen," Newton said. "I love me some Josh. He's probably my favorite player to watch. But he don't get the blame like everybody else. You would think that with all the talent he has, he would be the reason why we win, not why we lose."

Newton's comments highlight the double standard surrounding Allen's performance, with some experts questioning whether he deserves to be considered one of the league's top quarterbacks.

The double standard

Newton believes that Allen is held to a different standard than other quarterbacks in the league. While Allen has been praised for his abilities, he has also been criticized for his inconsistent postseason play.

As Newton pointed out, "As if to say Josh Allen ain't the reason why his team lost the last game versus Denver. What you doing before the halftime? Talking about the top of the list, you're supposed to be the reason why we win, not why we lose."

Newton's comments are a reminder that the NFL is a league of double standards, where players are often held to different expectations based on their performance. While Allen has been praised for his abilities, he has also been criticized for his inconsistent postseason play.

The future of Josh Allen

The question remains whether Allen will be able to overcome his inconsistent postseason play and become one of the league's top quarterbacks. Only time will tell, but one thing is certain: the debate surrounding Allen's performance will continue to be a topic of discussion among NFL experts.

And with the 2026 season just around the corner, Allen will have another opportunity to prove himself as one of the league's top quarterbacks. But will he be able to overcome his inconsistent postseason play and become the leader of the Bills?

Only time will tell, but one thing is certain: the debate surrounding Allen's performance will continue to be a topic of discussion among NFL experts.

**PFN's FREE NFL Top 100 Builder**

**BE THE GM OF YOUR FAVORITE TEAM:** PFN's FREE NFL Mock Draft Simulator