Scott McTominay thrives at Napoli while Dele Alli flops in Serie A

Scott McTominay has turned his Serie A switch into a masterclass at Napoli, while Dele Alli’s shock Como move has flopped spectacularly.

What’s the difference between McTominay and Alli?

McTominay, 25, has slotted seamlessly into Napoli’s midfield under Rudi Garcia, delivering energy and control. Alli, 27, has struggled to replicate his Premier League form at Como since his shock summer move. The contrast highlights how McTominay’s transfer has worked while Alli’s hasn’t.

Why did McTominay’s Napoli move click?

McTominay joined Napoli in July 2024 for a reported £35m. He’s started 18 of 22 Serie A games this season, averaging 85 passes per match. His work rate-3.2 tackles and 2.1 interceptions per game-has given Napoli a new edge in midfield battles. Garcia’s system suits his physicality and stamina, unlike Alli’s rigid role at Como.

Where did Alli go wrong at Como?

Alli’s Como switch in January 2025 shocked Serie A fans. He’s played 12 games, with zero goals and one assist. His £10m fee now looks steep as Como sit 14th, just two points clear of relegation. Former teammate Scott McTominay, meanwhile, has helped Napoli chase a top-four finish.

What’s next for both players?

McTominay could push for a Champions League spot with Napoli. Alli’s future is murkier-Como’s relegation battle may force a January exit. McTominay’s rise contrasts with Alli’s decline, proving how a move’s success hinges on fit, not just the club’s ambition.